All Souls Church Developmental Ministry
About All Souls Church Developmental Ministry
In the summer of 2024, Rev. Anastassia Zinke joined All Souls Church as our Developmental Minister. We hired her to lead us on a journey of collective learning and growth known as Developmental Ministry. Developmental Ministry can help congregations with serious, and often chronic, structural or spiritual issues to understand cycles of burnout, conflict, and turnover. By working together to understand and address the reasons for these patterns, Developmental Ministry can help us build a more engaged, joyful, healthy, and resilient spiritual community. This in turn puts us on the strong and sustainable footing that we need for a successful settled ministry.
-
● Carrying forward the capital campaign to a successful completion;
● Effectively managing needed building repairs and advancing the Church's long-term financial plan;
● Being faithful stewards of our financial obligations now and in the future;
● Considering our potential for growth.
-
● Holding ourselves accountable to the living practice of our covenant of right relations;
● Working to build a diverse multicultural Beloved Community by our actions that accountably dismantle racism and other oppressions in ourselves and our institutions;
● Creating meaningful experiences of belonging for all members of our community, whether they participate in person or virtually;
● Engaging in collective learning on how to welcome and support leaders with marginalized identities.
-
● Building a shared understanding of committee, staff, board and congregational roles and responsibilities, so that we can more effectively work together in carrying out these goals;
● Evaluating strengths and opportunities for improvement that would better enable us to meet our other Developmental Ministry goals, including our antiracism and anti-oppression commitments.
Each of these goals is focused on an important area where All Souls has struggled over the years. Goal 1 seeks to understand and address years of structural deficits and weak financial controls, as well as to secure the financing and technical expertise to address the longstanding neglect of our historic building. Goal 2 recognizes our desire to break the cycles of recurring conflict – often racialized – that keeps us from fully achieving our vision of Beloved Community. We can learn how to better address conflicts that have amplified divisions, fueled departures, and caused members to feel disengaged or demoralized. Goal 3 clearly frames the work needed to ensure our underlying processes, structures and systems enable us to achieve our other two goals.
And we know that this work will be worth it because of the vision it supports:A congregation that gives joyously and generously enough to sustain our mission. We spend what we budget and account for what we spend, finances are transparent, and the mortgage is sustainable. The steeple and courtyard are finished and the building is a safe, welcoming, comfortable and efficient home for us and for the community at large. The congregation knows its own story, can speak appropriately with pride and appreciation, but also with honesty and without blaming when it comes to the painful chapters. When someone makes a mistake, whether as a congregant or in leadership, the community names it, repairs it, and moves on. Staff have been here long enough to trust one another and the congregation, and the congregation trusts them. Everyone understands their role in shared ministry, processes are clear and coherent, and the operations support all aspects of the mission.
Image of Rev. Anastassia on a Sunday morning, preaching to children during Time For All Ages
How We Began This Journey
In the spring of 2022, All Souls launched a ministerial search, led by a search committee, to find our next called minister. Over a two-year period we planned to work to find our next settled senior minister, who would begin in the summer of 2024. About a year later, in May of 2023, the Board announced a change in plans. All Souls had been working with the UUA to evaluate our situation and came to the conclusion we should defer our search. At the time, Rev. Bill Sinkford was serving as our Transitions Minister, and he helped guide the Board through this decision. One particular concern was the dire condition of the building, which needed a capital campaign and multi-million dollar repairs. Another was the condition of our community, which was continuing to experience cycles of unhealthy conflict. Rev. Bill and the Board believed that doing this work now would help us be ready for settled ministry.
Our Goals
A Developmental Ministry focuses on specific named goals. We named three goals for All Souls to achieve through this ministry:
Our Timeline
Our community’s developmental ministry work, like any deep growth work, will take time. We know that addressing our building and financial needs are a top priority and that they remain a work in progress. We know that we cannot do everything at once, that our goals are large, and complex, and that repair and restoration cannot happen without a deep understanding and shared recognition of the root cause of our challenges.
The UUA advises that Developmental Ministry is a 4 to 7 year journey, and that five years is typical. Based on that experience, the Board entered into an initial four-year contract with Rev. Anastassia, with options for annual renewal after that, for a total term of up to seven years. We have committed to a check-in with the UUA’s transitions office before every renewal to make sure that we are making accountable progress on our developmental goals and to determine whether a renewal is in the best interest of the congregation.
We have spent the first two years making significant progress. We have set up a Sustainable Building Task Force, supported by Bob Polite, which has addressed a number of critical life safety systems; is preparing to launch a repair of our church steeple; and who will oversee in future years the completion of the courtyard repairs. We have moved significantly towards shared ministry, which is being supported by a revived, Church Council, and that includes members in critical operational as well as program ministries. Strong examples of this are our lay communications team and our steller pastoral associates, both of which fulfill functions formerly held by paid professionals. Participation in our choir, in Jubilee Singers, and in religious education is growing.. After a serious and unanticipated financial crisis in the spring of 2026, we are rebuilding our financial controls, budgeting and financial management back stronger and more transparently. We have a leaner and more sustainable operational budget. Our Staff and Workplace Culture Committee is active and is helping our Developmental Minister and Board ensure that All Souls is acting as a diligent and responsible employer. We are learning that conflict does not have to be an existential threat and that we can respond to our challenges with love, resilience and generosity. We have more work ahead to reach the place where a settled ministry can thrive, but we are on the path.
The Board and Developmental Minister are committed to focusing this year on how to assess our progress and readiness, and to partnering with the congregation on how we approach that. We have already set specific goals for this year, and we want to be accountable for our progress. We are working toward a clear timeline for this next phase of Developmental Ministry and will continue to be in dialogue with our staff, lay leaders and the congregation as a whole as we develop it.
